Title: Huntress
Author: Malinda Lo
Published: Little, Brown Books for Young Readers, 2011
Rating: 3 of 5
Page Count: 395
Total Page Count: 314,155
Text Number: 1077
Read Because: continuing the series, ebook borrowed from the Multnomah County Library
Review: Generations before Ash, a group of humans make an unusual journey to the fairy court in hopes of ending an unnaturally long winter. I sometimes find overland journey narratives tedious or unstructured; sometimes, I love the emphasis they place on survival and growing camaraderie. This falls in the latter group, which may have as much to do with how long it's been since I encountered the structure as it does the book itself. The slow-burn intimacy particularly flatters the development of a romancebut, that said, what interests me most in the romance is the vision that presages it, and Matrix-like ("would you still have broken it if I hadn't said anything?"), I wish that had been a source of tension; what tensions exist instead, in the characters's diverging paths, I find less interesting.
The entire post-roadtrip section falters. The climax is in two parts, and the second part feels tacked on. I have complains re: plot holes (why summon a king when what they needed was a hunter?), and that the protagonist assumes her role out of necessity and because she has the ability, rather than because she finds any fulfillment in it, makes for an unsatisfying ending. The most egregious aspect is the headhopping, which should have been made into omniscient narrator but is instead messy and smacks of the worst of YA writing. This was still more enjoyable, if not more successful, than Ash, so I'm not sorry to've read it, but it has a gentle downward slope.
Title: Dream Animals: A Bedtime Story
Author: Emily Winfield Martin
Published: Random House Books for Young Readers, 2013
Rating: 4 of 5
Page Count: 35
Total Page Count: 314,190
Text Number: 1078
Read Because: personal enjoyment, board book borrowed from the Wilsonville Public Library
Review: A pleasure! Twee, absolutely, and I can't vouch for (nor do I honestly care about) "actually helps kids sleep"but playful, fantastic, with lush art; I can get behind this sort of fantasy idealization of a dreamland which largely reads like a loveletter to children's and MG literature. I'm glad I read this in print instead of digitally; the glossy prints are gorgeous.
(This is the second modern picture book I've encountered that depicts fish in 1-gallon fish bowls. Both were published around 2010when did we begin the cultural realization that these habitats are actually really awful? is this a cultural realization, yet, or just something I've been exposed to in my social circles? I'll admit to being (justifiably!) sensitive about idealized and/or outdated problematic depictions of pets in media, but the goldfish=fishbowl association really needs to die.)
Title: The Were-Wolf
Author: Clemence Housman
Published: Gutenberg, 2004 (1896)
Rating: 4 of 5
Page Count: 60
Total Page Count: 314,250
Text Number: 1079
Read Because: fan of the trope, ebook free from Gutenberg
Review: A woman in the arrives of wake of ominous portents, leaving wolf tracks behind her. This has held up phenomenally well since 1896. The antiquated language is a minor hurdle, especially in such a short text, and a beautiful but strong, axe-wielding woman who straddles gender stereotypes and has an erotic but ambiguous danger still feels progressive and still feels like a fresh take the werewolf trope. It's one of the more satisfying werewolf narratives I've encountered: the climax is an extended, grueling, numinous chase; it's a fulfilling take on an aspect of the trope which is generally underutilized. There are flaws elsewherethe slow build and overdrawn resolution are effective but nothing exceptionalbut that middle section is flawless and won me entirely.
Title: The Pervert
Author: Michelle Perez
Illustrator: Remy Boydell
Published: Image Comics, 2018
Rating: 3 of 5
Page Count: 160
Total Page Count: 314,410
Text Number: 1086
Read Because: fan of the author group, paperbacks borrowed from the Wilsonville Public Library
Review: on this list of graphic novels about queer women, paper back borrowed from the Wilsonville Public Library
Review: The chronicles of a sex worker in Seattle as she progresses through her transition. All the reviews remarking on how the anthropomorphic art contrast the mature issues of sex work and trans* identity are hilariousit's just furry art, y'all; it's gonna be okay. I'm not enamored of thisthere's a roughness, both in the art (the lingering pencil lines tip it from "raw" to "messy") and in the writing, which is poorly condensed to the point of incoherence. The overall effect I like better: it's honest, confrontational, personal, and complex; the vignette format builds into a nuanced portrait. This is worth reading, nonetheleast because it's so quick to read, but flawed.
Author: Malinda Lo
Published: Little, Brown Books for Young Readers, 2011
Rating: 3 of 5
Page Count: 395
Total Page Count: 314,155
Text Number: 1077
Read Because: continuing the series, ebook borrowed from the Multnomah County Library
Review: Generations before Ash, a group of humans make an unusual journey to the fairy court in hopes of ending an unnaturally long winter. I sometimes find overland journey narratives tedious or unstructured; sometimes, I love the emphasis they place on survival and growing camaraderie. This falls in the latter group, which may have as much to do with how long it's been since I encountered the structure as it does the book itself. The slow-burn intimacy particularly flatters the development of a romancebut, that said, what interests me most in the romance is the vision that presages it, and Matrix-like ("would you still have broken it if I hadn't said anything?"), I wish that had been a source of tension; what tensions exist instead, in the characters's diverging paths, I find less interesting.
The entire post-roadtrip section falters. The climax is in two parts, and the second part feels tacked on. I have complains re: plot holes (why summon a king when what they needed was a hunter?), and that the protagonist assumes her role out of necessity and because she has the ability, rather than because she finds any fulfillment in it, makes for an unsatisfying ending. The most egregious aspect is the headhopping, which should have been made into omniscient narrator but is instead messy and smacks of the worst of YA writing. This was still more enjoyable, if not more successful, than Ash, so I'm not sorry to've read it, but it has a gentle downward slope.
Title: Dream Animals: A Bedtime Story
Author: Emily Winfield Martin
Published: Random House Books for Young Readers, 2013
Rating: 4 of 5
Page Count: 35
Total Page Count: 314,190
Text Number: 1078
Read Because: personal enjoyment, board book borrowed from the Wilsonville Public Library
Review: A pleasure! Twee, absolutely, and I can't vouch for (nor do I honestly care about) "actually helps kids sleep"but playful, fantastic, with lush art; I can get behind this sort of fantasy idealization of a dreamland which largely reads like a loveletter to children's and MG literature. I'm glad I read this in print instead of digitally; the glossy prints are gorgeous.
(This is the second modern picture book I've encountered that depicts fish in 1-gallon fish bowls. Both were published around 2010when did we begin the cultural realization that these habitats are actually really awful? is this a cultural realization, yet, or just something I've been exposed to in my social circles? I'll admit to being (justifiably!) sensitive about idealized and/or outdated problematic depictions of pets in media, but the goldfish=fishbowl association really needs to die.)
Title: The Were-Wolf
Author: Clemence Housman
Published: Gutenberg, 2004 (1896)
Rating: 4 of 5
Page Count: 60
Total Page Count: 314,250
Text Number: 1079
Read Because: fan of the trope, ebook free from Gutenberg
Review: A woman in the arrives of wake of ominous portents, leaving wolf tracks behind her. This has held up phenomenally well since 1896. The antiquated language is a minor hurdle, especially in such a short text, and a beautiful but strong, axe-wielding woman who straddles gender stereotypes and has an erotic but ambiguous danger still feels progressive and still feels like a fresh take the werewolf trope. It's one of the more satisfying werewolf narratives I've encountered: the climax is an extended, grueling, numinous chase; it's a fulfilling take on an aspect of the trope which is generally underutilized. There are flaws elsewherethe slow build and overdrawn resolution are effective but nothing exceptionalbut that middle section is flawless and won me entirely.
Title: The Pervert
Author: Michelle Perez
Illustrator: Remy Boydell
Published: Image Comics, 2018
Rating: 3 of 5
Page Count: 160
Total Page Count: 314,410
Text Number: 1086
Read Because: fan of the author group, paperbacks borrowed from the Wilsonville Public Library
Review: on this list of graphic novels about queer women, paper back borrowed from the Wilsonville Public Library
Review: The chronicles of a sex worker in Seattle as she progresses through her transition. All the reviews remarking on how the anthropomorphic art contrast the mature issues of sex work and trans* identity are hilariousit's just furry art, y'all; it's gonna be okay. I'm not enamored of thisthere's a roughness, both in the art (the lingering pencil lines tip it from "raw" to "messy") and in the writing, which is poorly condensed to the point of incoherence. The overall effect I like better: it's honest, confrontational, personal, and complex; the vignette format builds into a nuanced portrait. This is worth reading, nonetheleast because it's so quick to read, but flawed.