Spoopy picture books are the most hit and miss of my picture book readings (makes sense, picking by theme rather than by author I trust/enjoy), but they sure are a vibe. Poesy the Monster Slayer is the only good one of this batch; Mr. Pumpkin's Tea Party is the best to look at.
Title: The Little Ghost Who Was a Quilt
Author: Riel Nason
Illustrator: Byron Eggenschwiler
Published: Tundra Books, 2020
Rating: 2 of 5
Page Count: 40
Total Page Count: 381,070
Text Number: 1434
Read Because: from this list of Halloween picture books, hardback borrowed from the Wilsonville Public Library
Review: Lovely color palette and pleasing artexcept, as usual for picture books, the humans. Aesthetically I dig the cozy Halloween vibes.
Thematically, this is on the nose (fine, for a picture book) and not very thoughtful. "Differences are what make individuals special" works, but "and when you recognize this, your differences will have no downside" doesn't work, given that the quilt ghost is effectively physically disabled, and "when other people recognize this, they'll stop bullying you and finally accept you as a friend, and this is a happy ending" is just gross, is what it is. I don't know that this hot take is necessaryplenty of picture books survive on vibes and good intentions, and their themes prove flawed on close reading. The issues here are really nothing more than, say ... Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer. Still, it soured my reading.
Title: Poesy the Monster Slayer
Author: Cory Doctorow
Illustrator: Matt Rockefeller
Published: First Second, 2020
Rating: 3.5 of 5
Page Count: 40
Total Page Count: 519,495
Text Number: 1892
Read Because: from this list of spooky picture books, hardback borrowed from the Timberland Regional Library
Review: A very Halloweeny read, with the familiar list of cliché monsters and a vibrant nighttime color palette. This is very fun, very tight & polished, verging on overwritten (both narrative and art). So it lacks the larger-than-itself weirdness and liminality that makes a picture book really memorableironic, as it's about an overactive imaginationbut I like it fine.
(Also the parents are so unnecessarily hot, so, thanks for that, Rockefeller, I guess??)
Title: Mr. Pumpkin's Tea Party
Author: Erin Barker
Published: blue manatee press, 2019
Rating: 3 of 5
Page Count: 30
Total Page Count: 524,640
Text Number: 1917
Read Because: this list, hardback borrowed from the Timberland Regional Library
Review: Adorable illustrations, rich watercolors with an abundance of spoopy, cozy, whimsical autumnal vibes. But it's a counting book, and not a great one: the vocabulary may be too advanced for that age, some panels ("eleven" is the worst offender) aren't great counting material, and the writing is a failed attempted at lyrical. I wish this had picked a direction, either aged down with better counting or, more likely, aged up with a richer narrative, because what's here is lovely to look at but hollow.
Title: Grobblechops
Author: Elizabeth Laird
Illustrator: Jenny Lucander
Published: Tiny Owl, 2019
Rating: 2.5 of 5
Page Count: 30
Total Page Count: 524,670
Text Number: 1918
Read Because: this list, hardback borrowed from the Timberland Regional Library
Review: A befriending of the monster under the bed, which is a productive, endearing process. It's the art that gets me. I love running background details like the teddy bear, and the monster design is a little doughy but certainly unique. But the human figures ... I always struggle with people in picture books, but this is the most off-putting I've ever found them, and combined with the skewed perspectives and proportions I found this the wrong kind of unsettling.
Title: The Little Ghost Who Was a Quilt
Author: Riel Nason
Illustrator: Byron Eggenschwiler
Published: Tundra Books, 2020
Rating: 2 of 5
Page Count: 40
Total Page Count: 381,070
Text Number: 1434
Read Because: from this list of Halloween picture books, hardback borrowed from the Wilsonville Public Library
Review: Lovely color palette and pleasing artexcept, as usual for picture books, the humans. Aesthetically I dig the cozy Halloween vibes.
Thematically, this is on the nose (fine, for a picture book) and not very thoughtful. "Differences are what make individuals special" works, but "and when you recognize this, your differences will have no downside" doesn't work, given that the quilt ghost is effectively physically disabled, and "when other people recognize this, they'll stop bullying you and finally accept you as a friend, and this is a happy ending" is just gross, is what it is. I don't know that this hot take is necessaryplenty of picture books survive on vibes and good intentions, and their themes prove flawed on close reading. The issues here are really nothing more than, say ... Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer. Still, it soured my reading.
Title: Poesy the Monster Slayer
Author: Cory Doctorow
Illustrator: Matt Rockefeller
Published: First Second, 2020
Rating: 3.5 of 5
Page Count: 40
Total Page Count: 519,495
Text Number: 1892
Read Because: from this list of spooky picture books, hardback borrowed from the Timberland Regional Library
Review: A very Halloweeny read, with the familiar list of cliché monsters and a vibrant nighttime color palette. This is very fun, very tight & polished, verging on overwritten (both narrative and art). So it lacks the larger-than-itself weirdness and liminality that makes a picture book really memorableironic, as it's about an overactive imaginationbut I like it fine.
(Also the parents are so unnecessarily hot, so, thanks for that, Rockefeller, I guess??)
Title: Mr. Pumpkin's Tea Party
Author: Erin Barker
Published: blue manatee press, 2019
Rating: 3 of 5
Page Count: 30
Total Page Count: 524,640
Text Number: 1917
Read Because: this list, hardback borrowed from the Timberland Regional Library
Review: Adorable illustrations, rich watercolors with an abundance of spoopy, cozy, whimsical autumnal vibes. But it's a counting book, and not a great one: the vocabulary may be too advanced for that age, some panels ("eleven" is the worst offender) aren't great counting material, and the writing is a failed attempted at lyrical. I wish this had picked a direction, either aged down with better counting or, more likely, aged up with a richer narrative, because what's here is lovely to look at but hollow.
Title: Grobblechops
Author: Elizabeth Laird
Illustrator: Jenny Lucander
Published: Tiny Owl, 2019
Rating: 2.5 of 5
Page Count: 30
Total Page Count: 524,670
Text Number: 1918
Read Because: this list, hardback borrowed from the Timberland Regional Library
Review: A befriending of the monster under the bed, which is a productive, endearing process. It's the art that gets me. I love running background details like the teddy bear, and the monster design is a little doughy but certainly unique. But the human figures ... I always struggle with people in picture books, but this is the most off-putting I've ever found them, and combined with the skewed perspectives and proportions I found this the wrong kind of unsettling.