It's the right time of year for Practical Magic* but it's no longer on Netflix and the disc I usually watch was borrowed from Dev's mother and thus did not make the move with us. So I glanced at the local library collection to see if they had it on shelvesand they don't (maybe I'll put a hold on it), but that act of glancing made a lightbulb go off in my brain:
I can ... get movies that Netflix doesn't have & which I don't want to buy ... from the library....
I knew this but did not internalize it until I did the thing. I tend to find the pacing of shows more accessible than films, and I'd rather read than either, so I don't watch a lot of movies or want to. But I have wanted to catch up on a few that speak to my niche interests, so play "spot the trend."
The Shape of Water, film, 2017, dir. Guillermo del Toro
On one hand I value that we can imagine monster-romance in terms only slightly weirder than any starcrossed/cultural-divide romance; there's power in normalizing and subverting the otherness of the Other. ...But also this is so unchallenging as to be bland: hammy antagonists; a monster almost without danger (would that the "danger" scene were anything other than ( spoiler ), because a) it's poorly handled, tonally and b) I knew it was coming & wasn't okay with it, so skipped past it, which removed what little danger does exist); it's insufficiently weird where ramping up the weirdness would compliment the theme of acceptance. There will one day be a del Toro movie that, like Pan's Labyrinth, I love rather than only admiring, and this wasn't it.
Venom, film, 2018, dir. Ruben Fleischer
This is what I wanted The Shape of Water to be, although it absolutely wants for the former's diversity and explicit text rather than romcom subtext (although it does has some Woke touches/trope subversions which I appreciate, like a male protagonist not owed access to his love interest). But what a delight! and this from someone with no interest in Marvel, comedy, or action. The first third is plot-heavy and slow, but the symbiont dynamic is the meat of the movie and has danger, weirdness, and chemistry. Danger-to-humans is a better routeit should have higher stakes, but it's more familiar and less squicky; not-quite-cannibalism reintroduces the squick and keeps things productively weird. The dark humor is what rides the action/buddy/romcom edge, and Tom Hardy is really gross (in a productive, good acting way) as Eddie and incredible as Venom's voice. The CGI is a lot, and inevitable, but killed things for me a bit: I couldn't ground myself in the action where 95% of what's on screen is digital, and there's Eddie/Venom convos where all I could think of was "Dobby was a tennis ball on a stick and it sure must be hard to make eye-contact with that." I have nitpicks, it's a trash movie, but this trash was made for me. Thank you for my trash, Marvel.
Further #monsterfucker films to add to my list seem surprisingly thin on the ground? I had the impression that this was a huge trend when by the time Venom came out, but in retrospect I suspect that was mostly a Shape of Water/It/Venom overlap, which feels like a lot in a short period but is not a lot cumulatively. And on the subject of It: I adore Bill SkarsgÄrd but hate that damn book and also clowns, so no thank you, and more pertinently I feel like that was less "conversations about sexy Otherness" and more "society sexualizes white male actors/characters with no regard for their actual narrative role." Similarly, while anything with monsters is monsterfucker material if you try hard enough, it's that "conversations about sexy Otherness" that I want. :(
But I do have unrelated things on my list, and things to watch with Devon!
* Which is not Halloween-inappropriate, but is definitely best suited for summer. (And takes place sometime after the summer solstice! And has that dialog line about "early for roses" which tries to muddy the timeline as June-ish is rose season, but let's attribute that to a script writing error and/or the wibbly wobbly timey wimey effects of long summer days and also magic.)
I can ... get movies that Netflix doesn't have & which I don't want to buy ... from the library....
I knew this but did not internalize it until I did the thing. I tend to find the pacing of shows more accessible than films, and I'd rather read than either, so I don't watch a lot of movies or want to. But I have wanted to catch up on a few that speak to my niche interests, so play "spot the trend."
The Shape of Water, film, 2017, dir. Guillermo del Toro
On one hand I value that we can imagine monster-romance in terms only slightly weirder than any starcrossed/cultural-divide romance; there's power in normalizing and subverting the otherness of the Other. ...But also this is so unchallenging as to be bland: hammy antagonists; a monster almost without danger (would that the "danger" scene were anything other than ( spoiler ), because a) it's poorly handled, tonally and b) I knew it was coming & wasn't okay with it, so skipped past it, which removed what little danger does exist); it's insufficiently weird where ramping up the weirdness would compliment the theme of acceptance. There will one day be a del Toro movie that, like Pan's Labyrinth, I love rather than only admiring, and this wasn't it.
Venom, film, 2018, dir. Ruben Fleischer
This is what I wanted The Shape of Water to be, although it absolutely wants for the former's diversity and explicit text rather than romcom subtext (although it does has some Woke touches/trope subversions which I appreciate, like a male protagonist not owed access to his love interest). But what a delight! and this from someone with no interest in Marvel, comedy, or action. The first third is plot-heavy and slow, but the symbiont dynamic is the meat of the movie and has danger, weirdness, and chemistry. Danger-to-humans is a better routeit should have higher stakes, but it's more familiar and less squicky; not-quite-cannibalism reintroduces the squick and keeps things productively weird. The dark humor is what rides the action/buddy/romcom edge, and Tom Hardy is really gross (in a productive, good acting way) as Eddie and incredible as Venom's voice. The CGI is a lot, and inevitable, but killed things for me a bit: I couldn't ground myself in the action where 95% of what's on screen is digital, and there's Eddie/Venom convos where all I could think of was "Dobby was a tennis ball on a stick and it sure must be hard to make eye-contact with that." I have nitpicks, it's a trash movie, but this trash was made for me. Thank you for my trash, Marvel.
Further #monsterfucker films to add to my list seem surprisingly thin on the ground? I had the impression that this was a huge trend when by the time Venom came out, but in retrospect I suspect that was mostly a Shape of Water/It/Venom overlap, which feels like a lot in a short period but is not a lot cumulatively. And on the subject of It: I adore Bill SkarsgÄrd but hate that damn book and also clowns, so no thank you, and more pertinently I feel like that was less "conversations about sexy Otherness" and more "society sexualizes white male actors/characters with no regard for their actual narrative role." Similarly, while anything with monsters is monsterfucker material if you try hard enough, it's that "conversations about sexy Otherness" that I want. :(
But I do have unrelated things on my list, and things to watch with Devon!
* Which is not Halloween-inappropriate, but is definitely best suited for summer. (And takes place sometime after the summer solstice! And has that dialog line about "early for roses" which tries to muddy the timeline as June-ish is rose season, but let's attribute that to a script writing error and/or the wibbly wobbly timey wimey effects of long summer days and also magic.)